Ruminating over Titanic

Friday, April 10, 2020

On April 10th, 1912, the "unsinkable" masterpiece Titanic set sail from Southampton in England on its maiden voyage, heading to New York City where it was supposed to dock on April 17th. Titanic stopped in Cherbourgh, France later on the 10th and Queenstown, Ireland on the 11th for additional passengers before making its way out to the open seas of the Atlantic, carrying 2,222 souls on board, counting passengers and crew.

Human nature wants to give a reason for this tragedy. There are more than enough theories running around the table as to why Titanic sank. The walls separating the bulkheads weren't sealed all the way to the top. That's weird. And unthinkable. Would Titanic have still sunk if the walls had gone all the way to the top? Maybe, maybe not. If we go that route then it's the fault of the ship's architect, Thomas Andrews, who nobly and tragically died on Titanic. Or it could be because there were no binoculars in the crow's nest for the lookouts so when the iceberg loomed out of the mist, the lookouts were only able to give First Officer Murdoch a 37-second warning to avoid the collision. But binoculars aren't common for lookouts because they actually inhibit their viewing range, so they can't really be considered at fault either. And no one can turn a ship the size of Titanic with only 37-seconds of warning. Then there are the 7 icebergs spotted on the 14th, but Captain Smith barreled on at full speed because the managing director of the White Star Line, Bruce Ismay, wanted to make the crossing in just 6 days.

Fault, as it were, could lie with any number of individuals, but honestly, Titanic sank because these things happen. Life happens, whether we want it to or not, and in the case of Titanic, the blame cannot be fully placed anywhere. A lot of little things added up to one massive tragedy that still fascinates the world today. It's remarkable to me that after all these years of knowing about the tragedy, that I haven't become jaded by it yet. I can watch a documentary on the sinking and tears still fill my eyes over the sheer loss of life that resulted from this tragedy. 

Over the next couple of days, I plan to watch the following films and maybe a few documentaries on Titanic: A Night to Remember (1958), Titanic (1953), and, of course, James Cameron's Titanic (1997). I've watched all of these films before, Cameron's film multiple times, but I think my favorite is A Night to Remember because it feels authentic to me since the sinking was still very much in living memory in the 1950s. It may seem morbid to spend time on such a tragedy right now while going through the COVID-19 pandemic, but I actually find comfort in tragedies that are different from what we're currently experiencing around the world. Despite all the tragedy, the world spins on. It will have a different look when we're on the other side of the pandemic and we may have different priorities than what we had previously. Many of us will have experienced loss by the end. Actually, maybe it makes this the perfect time to delve into the history of the Titanic.

My Posts Related to Titanic in 2020




A photo of the Titanic

7 comments

  1. I'm going to throw myself a mini TITANIC tea on the anniversary and watch the Cameron film also. Watching it is my annual tradition and honestly? It will cheer me up.

    I wish Easter wasn't so close to it this year, I'm watching various Jesus-related things at the moment and may not be able to squeeze in A Night to Remember this year. Ah well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Awwwww, I wish I was with you. What are you making? I believe I was with you at last one year during the anniversary.

      I just finished watching A Night to Remember with Caitlin. I'd forgotten how brilliant it is. Lightoller is a true hero in that one; I just love how they brought his character so strongly to the forefront.

      It is kind of funny how close Easter and Titanic are, in addition to my mother's birthday tomorrow. It's so crazy. I may watch Risen or give The Chosen a try since you recommended it and it sounds intriguing. I'm glad to hear it's not as violent as A.D.. That's a plus!

      We also watched Titanic from 1953. You should have heard Caitlin groan and whine in horror over the costumes. I admit, they were gorgeous for the 1950s, but absolutely horrendous for an Edwardian piece. At least A Night to Remember got the clothing mostly right, especially those lovely, enormous hats the ladies all wore.

      It's been helping to think of Titanic since it's taking my mind off the insanity of the world at the moment. Right now I find myself nervous to just step out my front door. I never imagined that could possibly happen!

      Delete
    2. You and Hannah were both here, and it was shortly after the Blu Ray release, and we had all manner of tasty treats. This year I'm going with the spinach canapes I served you once, tea, raspberry scones and chocolate mousse. And I wish you could be here, too. :P

      Yes, it's a wonderful movie and I adore Lightoller in that. Not a bad Thomas Andrews, either. I think one of my favorite Lightoller scenes is at the end, when he's guiding the boat to the Carpathia. Didn't they put frost in his hair, just like IRL? I haven't seen the old Titanic in ages but... yes, the costumes were not at all Edwardian. Silly classic Hollywood. It's never right. ;)

      The Chosen is much tamer and has a lower budget than A.D. I finished it, and am now watching A.D. I love the latter also but can see why my mother didn't like it -- it is very violent. But I just reached the point where Saul is introduced, so I'm pumped. Who knew he'd become my favorite character alongside Peter? Kudos to them for that.

      Being stuck at home ought to give us a little more empathy for the Jews during the time of Jesus. Instead of a virus, they had the Romans to worry about -- who picked and chose people to kill at random. :P

      Delete
    3. Ahhhh, that's right. My goodness that's been awhile!

      Indeed, I liked both their Thomas Andrews and their Lightoller. I love that they showed such a sweet family life scene for Andrews at the beginning of the film. And yes, they did put frost in Lightoller's hair and eyebrows. It was quite convincing!

      Delete
  2. Very nice post! I've never heard of A Night To Remember, I'll have to check it out. I'm planning on sitting my Mom and sister down to watch Titanic: The Musical put on by The Kings Academy on YouTube. It's soooooo good!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, Grace, thanks for following my blog! I followed yours too and may join in your read-a-thon, even though I'm a little late. I'll see if my library has an e-copy of the book you're reading. :)

      A Night to Remember is a superb film and very accurate to the history of the sinking, with very little flowery extras added. It's also quite beautiful and the historic clothing is fairly correct, something my sister and I both appreciate.

      I had no idea that anyone had made a Titanic musical! I may have to track that down as well. I hope your mom and sister enjoy it. :)

      Delete
    2. Awww, thanks so much, we'd love to have you join us! Your not late everyone else is simply early!! If you can't find it at your library, Gutenberg Press has it.
      I love the musical very much and my sister did like it, even though she put up a fuss about watching it! Mom fell asleep!!!!
      I look forward to all you future posts!!

      Delete

Thank you for your kind comments, which I adore!